How Much does it Cost to Hire a Property Manager?

Published: Jan 26, 2022

How do property management companies price their services? What can you expect the cost of hiring a property manager to include?

You should be able to assess price versus value when you’re hiring your next property manager at your investment property.

Here, you will learn how much you can expect to spend on professional property management.  You can also discover what to look for when measuring service and value.

Understanding the Property Management Fee

The largest fee that everyone looks at when evaluating property management services is the monthly management fee. This is almost always a percentage of monthly rent a property management company collects from the tenant and charges the owner. Property owners can expect to pay this fee every month. This ends up being the largest chunk of the overall property management cost.

What is a Typical Property Management Fee?

Percentage Based Property Management Fees

Typically, the property management fee varies between 6% and 12%, depending on where in the state, city or even neighborhood you are located in. The property management costs also depend on what types of services you’re choosing and receiving.

When a property management company collects your monthly rent, they will deduct the percentage that you owe to them in a management fee before forwarding the balance of the rent onto you.

Flat Rate Property Management Fees

Sometimes, you may come across a property manager who will offer flat rate monthly fees. There is no right or wrong option.

When it comes to flat fees, the costs are not associated with monthly rent being collected.

Flat rate fees are generally more simple and transparent. There are no calculations involved to determine what your monthly management costs will add up to.

These flat rate fees will inevitably vary by market, as do percentage based plans since they are based on monthly rent being collected.

What are Challenges Assessing Fees for Property Management?

One of the challenges that property owners like you might face when pricing services and evaluating management companies is that most property managers don’t publish their price on their website.

This has always been a mystery to us. Why wouldn’t they list their price for you to see?

If you’re a consumer who is looking for a product or a service to buy, you want to know the price of that product or service. You wouldn’t buy something without knowing how much it costs.

So, look for pricing information when you’re searching for property management companies. Search for information on local companies that are not afraid to list their prices on the website or platform. If you come across a company who does this, you’ve found yourself a good starting point. Companies who hide their property management fees and avoid transparency are not building trust with their owners properly.

Property owners and investors want to be informed on how to make the best choice. If the pricing isn’t published already, you have to spend valuable time asking about prices instead of talking about services.

Leasing and Lease Renewal Fees: What to Expect

There are some other important fees that you’ll need to consider in addition to the monthly property management fee. There’s the leasing fee, which is something you can expect to pay one time, at the beginning of a tenancy.

What are Typical Leasing Fees?

The leasing fee is typically between 50 percent and 100 percent of your first month’s rent. Some companies may charge a flat leasing fee.

This covers the cost of a property manager to advertise your home, market the property, manage applications, screen tenants, and then negotiate and execute the lease and move those tenants into your property.

What are Typical Lease Renewal Fees?

The next largest fee for property owners to expect is the lease renewal fee. When the lease term is about to end, your property manager will work with the tenant on either renewing the lease or moving the tenant out. There may be a rental increase to negotiate or some other change in terms. Some property management companies will charge as much as $300 for a lease renewal, maybe even more depending on your market.

Other property managers will charge as little as $150 or even less. Some companies charge nothing – they don’t have a lease renewal fee. There is no single right way to do it; just make sure you understand how much you’ll be charged, and when.

This is one of the fees you should always evaluate when you’re looking at property managers. Always measure the complete cost of professional management when deciding who to work with.

Paying for Repair and Maintenance Mark-Ups

Property maintenance at rental home add to costs for management

Another big cost for many property owners, depending on the management company they choose, is rental property repair and maintenance mark-ups.

Not every company charges this fee. Some will charge an average of 10 percent to oversee any maintenance or repairs your property may undergo during the lease period.

Think about when a tenant calls to report a leak. The process may look like this:

  • A plumber goes out to your property and fixes the leak.
  • The cost for this, estimated $400, may get marked up by your property manager.
  • The company may assess a 10 percent mark-up on that invoice.
  • On a $400 bill, that would be $40. So, your complete maintenance invoice would be $440.

Make sure you’re aware of this cost before you sign a management agreement.

You don’t want to be surprised when you receive an accounting statement or an expense report. A good property manager will let you know that property maintenance fees are part of their fee schedule.

Understanding the Complete Cost of Professional Property Management

In addition to the popular fees that we have already mentioned, you can find a parade of other fees and charges. You might come across a management company that just charges one fee that includes everything. Or, you’ll find companies that charge you separately for every service.

You might find:

  • administrative fees
  • setup fees
  • technology fees
  • accounting fees
  • vacancy fees
  • tax preparation fees
  • and on and on

Make sure you understand that not only are you paying six or 12 percent in a management fee; you’re also getting other things that aren’t initially included in the pricing table. You want to understand the entire cost of management with a company so you can make the best decision.

Property Management Discounts and Guarantees

Maybe you’d like to get a discount?

Many property management companies will offer discounts to owners who have more than one properties that needs managing. If you own an entire portfolio or several units in a multi-unit building, then you really have some buying power.

Discuss the reduced rate for your two, three or even six or 10 properties. You can easily negotiate a better deal for yourself.

What Sort of Property Manager Guarantees Should I Look For?

In addition to discounts, you should also talk to any potential property management company about the guarantees they may provide.

Lately, the property management industry as a whole has been discussing the importance of alignment between our customers.

Landlords and tenants are both being served by the property management companies. Their services should reflect that. Many investment property companies have started offering guarantees to bridge that gap.

When you look at guarantees, make sure you’re carefully reading the fine print. A rent guarantee could just be a discount on the management fee while your property is being re-leased. That may be called a rent guarantee, but they aren’t actually guaranteeing your rent.

Instead, they’re guaranteeing you won’t be charged their normal management fee while leasing the property to new tenants.

That’s something, but there’s not a lot of value in such a guarantee. If you come across a company that offers a real rent guarantee, it should mean that you’re getting rental income every month.  

Whether your property is vacant or your tenants aren’t paying rent, this guarantee would ensure monthly rent. Maybe you’re waiting for a new tenant to move in. A good rental income guarantee will ensure that you are still getting paid. Study the guarantees that are being offered and make sure they fit what you need and want.

How Do Property Managers Price Their Services

As you can see and have probably realized by now, there are many different ways that property management companies will price their services.

It largely depends on:

  • The market you’re in
  • The services you require
  • The guarantees included
  • Cancellation fees

Some companies will have a single fixed price. It might be on the lower end; like six or eight percent, but then they will add a lot of extra fees. Other companies will have more transparency.

We like to see a three-tier table for pricing. You can choose Tier One, Tier Two, or Tier Three. It gives the property owner a lot more flexibility. You can migrate through different plans as your needs change.

So, you might go for the lowest plan now. But, keep in mind, when you move out of the county or add more properties to your portfolio, you might want to increase your plan.

Think about graduating from the least expensive plan to the most expensive. That way, you don’t have to worry about your property at all. You can evaluate your choices based on the level of stress you are wanting to avoid.

Three Final Tips on Property Management Company Pricing Evaluations

How much do property managers charge

Now that you know what to expect in terms of property management pricing, we have three final tips for you to consider before you decide who to hire.

Rental Property Management Cost Considerations:

  1. Why the secrecy? Be careful of the property managers who don’t want to publish their prices online. If a company doesn’t tell you ahead of time what they charge, you should ask why. Maybe they’re too expensive, and they don’t want to scare you off.
  2. Consistency. Perhaps, the company is charging on a property by property basis. They may not have a set pricing model. Those companies charge whatever they want to whoever they want and there’s no consistency.
  3. Calculate the total cost of management. Remember that a company charging a six percent management fee isn’t necessarily cheaper. The company charging a 10 percent management fee might cover or guarantee more.
  4. Look at the other monthly fees that are or are not included. The leasing fee might be a full month’s rent or there could be a huge maintenance mark-up. Maybe there aren’t any guarantees.
  5. Finally, look for clear and flexible options. You should have the choice of service levels.  You should also be able to easily understand the differences between Tier One and Tier Three.
  6. Are there cancellation options? Consider property management companies who will allow you to end the contract if the relationship is not working out. At some companies, you can expect to pay for the cancellation. Others offer worry-free cancellation.

And for the Bonus Tip – make sure a company’s guarantees align with your interests. Understand what each guarantee actually means.

At Mynd, we think like investors.

If you have any questions, please contact us at Mynd Property Management. We are growing fast, and it’s possible we’re servicing your market.

SUGGested reading

Are you looking to invest in rental property?

* For qualified investors with a minimum of $50,000 available to invest

Thank you for getting in touch!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Our team will reach out to you shortly to schedule a consultation.
Mynd recommends saving a minimum of $50,000 to cover a 30% down payment and closing costs.

In the meantime, learn more about ways to start with a smaller downpayment here.

Ready to speak with our sales team?

Start the conversation!


Thank you!

We received your information and will be contacting you shortly.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Are you looking to rent?

Click here to browse our listings and submit an application.